Sons of newly-identified Gilgo Beach homicide sufferer Karen Vergata ‘weren’t warned by police’

The sons of a newly-identified Gilgo Beach murders sufferer reportedly weren’t notified by Long Island police earlier than her title was revealed to the general public.

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney held a press convention on Friday to announce that the sufferer recognized solely as Jane Doe 7 had lastly been recognized as Karen Vergata, greater than 26 years after her partial stays had been first found alongside the Long Island shores.

Vergata, 34, was final seen alive in Manhattan in 1996 whereas working as an escort. The enormous breakthrough within the case comes virtually three a long time after a few of Vergata’s stays had been first found – and simply weeks after Rex Heuermann, a 59-year-old father-of-two architect, was arrested and charged with the murders of three different Gilgo Beach victims.

Mr Tierney informed reporters that Vergata had been positively recognized by way of DNA in August 2022 however investigators saved the event underneath wraps as a result of ongoing investigation into Mr Heuermann. Officials refused to touch upon whether or not or not her homicide could also be linked to the suspected serial killer.

The district legal professional additionally attributed the delay to the necessity to contact Vergata’s members of the family.

However, it has since emerged that Vergata’s two organic sons – Eric and Gary Doherty – apparently weren’t knowledgeable earlier than Friday’s announcement.

(Suffolk County DA)

Eric’s girlfriend Michelle Nolan informed the New York Post that he solely discovered after the press convention once they had been contacted by the girl who adopted them as younger youngsters a number of years earlier than Vergata’s loss of life.

Ms Nolan stated Eric was distraught, having believed that Vergata was solely lacking.

Mr Tierney’s workplace didn’t return the Post’s request for remark about household notification, the outlet reported.

Ms Nolan stated Eric and Gary grew up with little data of their organic mom after having been adopted by Edward and Diane Doherty in 1992.

She defined that Vergata had been struck by a truck whereas she was pregnant with Gary within the late Nineteen Eighties, which is believed to have led to him being born with cerebral palsy.

Shortly after Eric was born in 1990, Vergata “took off”, Ms Nolan stated.

“She was a drug user and their father took her and helped her,” she stated. Ms Nolan stated the boys’ father was believed to have died from tuberculosis, however she wasn’t positive when.

She stated that Gary is now dwelling in an facility for adults with particular wants and has not been knowledgeable about his mom’s loss of life.

Vergata vanished with out a hint round 14 February 1996 – Valentine’s Day, based on officers.

She lived on West forty fifth St in Manhattan and is believed to have been working as an escort on the time of her disappearance.

Police stated that no lacking individuals report was filed on the time.

On 20 April 1996, a girl’s legs had been discovered wrapped in plastic at Davis Park on Fire Island’s Blue Point Beach.

Almost precisely 15 years afterward 11 April 2011, the girl’s cranium was then discovered off Ocean Parkway in the course of the seek for Gilgo Beach victims. The cranium was situated near the stays of one other unidentified sufferer – Jane Doe 3, often known as Peaches.

The two units of stays in Fire Island and Ocean Parkway had been later discovered to belong to the identical individual.

Before now, investigators had lengthy been unable to establish Jane Doe 7 – and the sufferer turned often called Fire Island Jane Doe.

She was described solely as a white girl aged 18 to 50 years outdated who had a number of notable scars together with proof of surgical procedure on her left ankle.

She was certainly one of 11 victims whose stays had been discovered dumped alongside the shores of Gilgo Beach again in 2010 and 2011 – a number of of whom are additionally but to be recognized.

Investigators are seen looking out the shores of Gilgo Beach in 2011


Decades later, investigators had been lastly capable of establish Fire Island Jane Doe utilizing genetic geneaology and her surviving relations’ DNA.

In August 2022 – round six months after the brand new Gilgo Beach taskforce was launched – a DNA profile appropriate for genealogical comparability was developed from the stays of the sufferer, officers stated in a press convention on Friday.

The subsequent month, the FBI was capable of presumptively establish the sufferer utilizing genetic family tree as Vergata.

Then, that October, investigators tracked down a relative of Vergata and took a buccal swab. Using this, they had been capable of definitively id the sufferer as Vergata.

At Friday’s press convention, Mr Tierney stated investigators saved that breakthrough hidden till now because of each the continued investigation into Mr Heuermann and the necessity to contact all of Vergata’s members of the family.

“Prior to disclosing, we needed to contact all Vergata’s family members and around the same time we were beginning the grand jury confidential investigation into the murders of the victims known as the Gilgo 4,” he informed reporters.

”So we determined to not make it public… till the outcomes of that investigation turned public and we had made discover to Vergata’s household.”

He added: “Today we are here to announce that as part of the Gilgo taskforce’s reexamination of all evidence in the case we are able to identify Fire Island Jane Doe as Karen Vergata.”

“It is important that we remember and honour not only Ms Vergata but all the vicitms on Gilgo Beach,” he added.

While this marks a serious breakthrough within the case, many questions nonetheless stay.

In Friday’s press convention asserting her id, Suffolk County officers refused to take any questions and wouldn’t touch upon whether or not or not Vergata’s homicide may very well be the linked to Mr Heuermann – who has up to now been tied to 4 of the victims discovered alongside the Long Island shores.

At this time, nobody has been charged in connection to her murder and her explanation for loss of life is unknown.

Map displaying websites the place victims’ stays discovered alongside Gilgo Beach

(Suffolk County Police Department)

DA Tierney stated that whereas there are “no charges at this time”, that the “confidential investigation” is ongoing.

He wouldn’t verify or deny any ties to accused killer Rex Heuermann – or say if there was any potential suspects on his radar.

“We are going to continue to work this particular case as we did the Gilgo Four investigation,” he stated.

“We’re not going to comment on what – if any suspects – we developed at this time. This is a confidential investigation so I’m not going to be taking any questions.”

This main improvement comes as prosecutors are searching for to acquire a swab of DNA from Mr Heuermann, the person arrested and charged with the murders of three of the victims and suspected of a fourth killing.

In a court docket submitting this week, prosecutors stated that the DNA pattern would “provide further relevant evidence of the defendant’s identity as the perpetrator of the crime”.

Prosecutors have up to now obtained lots of of hours of footage from the suspect’s residence in Massapequa Park and his workplace in Midtown Manhattan, 2,500 pages of paperwork, crime scene pictures and post-mortem reviews within the high-profile case.

The trove of proof was turned over to Suffolk County Supreme Court Justice Timothy Mazzei and Mr Heuermann’s legal professional Michael Brown on Tuesday because the accused killer appeared in court docket for a short preliminary listening to.

Suffolk County DA Tierney stated final week {that a} “massive amount of evidence” had been recovered from the house which Mr Heuermann grew up in as a baby – and which he went on to share along with his household up till his sudden arrest.

No human stays had been found, however a trove of round 270 weapons had been seized from the house.

The DA beforehand revealed that they consider not less than a number of the murders might have taken place inside the house.

Mr Heuermann’s spouse and two grownup youngsters had been out of city on the time of every of the three murders he’s charged with, based on court docket information.

The 59-year-old architect was taken into custody on 13 July, virtually 13 years after the our bodies of not less than 11 victims had been found alongside the shores of Gilgo Beach on Long Island.

He was charged with the murders of Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy and Amber Costello.

He can also be the prime suspect within the homicide of Maureen Brainard-Barnes – who was final seen alive in early June 2007 in New York City and who, with the three different girls, is named the “Gilgo Four”.

Rex Heuermann appeared in court docket on Tuesday


All 4 girls labored as intercourse employees and disappeared after going to fulfill a shopper. They had been all present in December 2010 inside one-quarter mile of one another, certain by belts or tape and a few wrapped in burlap – their our bodies dumped alongside Gilgo Beach.

They are amongst 11 victims whose stays had been discovered alongside the shores of Long Island in 2010 and 2011, sparking fears of a number of serial killers.

As effectively as trying into his connection to the homicide of Brainard-Barnes and the opposite Gilgo Beach victims, regulation enforcement businesses at the moment are additionally trying into unsolved murders and lacking individuals circumstances all throughout the nation.

Police in Las Vegas and South Carolina – the place Mr Heuermann owns properties – and Atlantic City – the place a number of intercourse employees have been discovered murdered – have confirmed they’re eyeing the suspect in chilly circumstances.

Court information present that Mr Heuermann was linked to the “Gilgo Four” murders by a tip about his pickup truck, a stash of burner telephones, “sadistic” on-line searches, cellphone calls taunting victims’ households, his spouse’s hair discovered on the victims’ our bodies – and a pizza crust.

The first piece of the puzzle got here when a witness within the Amber Costello case revealed particulars a couple of car {that a} shopper was driving when she was final seen alive.

Costello, who labored as a intercourse employee, was seen alive on the night of two September 2010 when she left her residence in West Babylon. A witness stated she had gone to fulfill a shopper who was driving a first-generation Chevrolet Avalanche.

Last 12 months, a registration search confirmed that native man Mr Heuermann owned a first-generation mannequin of the truck on the time of Costello’s disappearance. He additionally matched the witness’ description of the person believed to be the killer: a big, white “ogre”-like male in his mid-40s, round 6’4’ to six’6” tall, with “dark bushy hair,” and “big oval style 1970’s type eyeglasses”.

Rex Heuermann’s residence being searched by investigators

(Copyright 2023 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.)

The discovery of the automotive led investigators to hone in on Mr Heuermann together with executing 300 subpoenas, search warrants and different authorized processes to acquire proof to find out his potential involvement within the killings.

Among this was Mr Heuermann’s alleged use of burner telephones, with prosecutors saying that he used burner telephones to contact the three girls and prepare to fulfill them on the time once they went lacking.

He additionally allegedly took two of the victims’ cellphones – and used one to make taunting cellphone calls to certainly one of their households the place he boasted about her homicide, court docket paperwork state.

Mr Heuermann’s DNA was discovered on one of many victims, whereas his spouse’s hair was discovered on three of the 4 girls he’s related to.

Following his arrest, his spouse Asa Ellerup filed for divorce. She has since informed The New York Post that she has been left stuffed with “anxiety” and their two youngsters “cry themselves to sleep” over the horror.

“I woke up in the middle of the night, shivering… anxiety,” she stated.

“My children cry themselves to sleep. I mean, they’re not children. They’re grown adults but they’re my children, and my son has developmental disabilities and he cried himself to sleep.”

Mr Heuermann’s sudden arrest comes after the horrific serial killer case has captured the nation’s consideration for greater than a decade.

The Gilgo Beach murders had lengthy stumped regulation enforcement officers in Suffolk County who believed it may very well be the work of a number of serial killers who focused intercourse employees and dumped their our bodies alongside the distant seashores on Ocean Parkway.

The case started in May 2010 when Shannan Gilbert vanished after leaving a shopper’s home on foot close to Gilgo Beach.

She known as 911 for assist saying she feared for her life and was by no means seen alive once more.

Crime scene investigators use metallic detectors to look a marsh for the stays of Shannan Gilbert in December 2011

During a seek for Gilbert in dense thicket near the seashore, police found the stays of one other girl.

Within a matter of days, the stays of three extra victims had been discovered shut by.

By spring 2011, the stays of a complete of 10 victims had been discovered together with eight girls, a person, and a toddler. Police have lengthy thought that it may very well be the work of a number of serial killers.

Gilbert’s physique was then present in December 2011. Her explanation for loss of life is extensively contested with authorities lengthy claiming that it isn’t related to the serial killer or killers however that she died from unintended drowning as she fled from the shopper’s residence.

However, an impartial post-mortem commissioned by her household dominated that she died by strangulation and her mom believes she was murdered.

Like Gilbert, many of the victims focused had been intercourse employees, whereas some are but to be recognized.

Leave a Comment